Showing posts with label Skottie Young. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Skottie Young. Show all posts

Sunday, May 25, 2014

The Latest Oz Reading

I may not have said a lot about what I'm reading lately, but I have been reading. So here's the latest recap of all kinds of Oz and related works I've read recently:

  • My weekends have become clearer (although still way too busy) recently, so I'm back to reading a short story from Oz Reimagined. First was "One Flew Over the Rainbow" by Robin Wasserman. As you can guess from the title, this one is set in an asylum, where three inmates help Dorothy escape. This ine just felt like an excuse to write a story set in an asylum, to be honest, with the Oz motifs tacked on.
  • The other story is "The Veiled Shanghai" by Ken Liu, and while it does the same as the previous story (basically retelling The Wizard of Oz in another setting), this one is so much richer and interesting. In 1919 Shanghai, Dorothy Gee lives with her Uncle Heng and Aunt En. Caught up in one of the riots during the May Fourth Movement, Dorothy is whisked away on a bus, only to wake up in the Veiled Shanghai, a parallel version of the city just out of reach of consciousness for most people. It's a little different, with magic, steampunk, and other aspects that confuse Dorothy, but she goes along with things anyway. The rest of the story is, as is traditional, the journey of her trying to get home and helping those she meets to achieve their goals. Scarecrow is an Iowa farmboy who stowed away on a freighter in San Francisco and wound up there. Tin Woodman was a woodchopper who allowed himself to be roboticized so that he could become more productive. Lion is an old Boxer who fled a battle during the Boxer Rebellion. And the Wicked Warlord is keeping China under his thumbs, until Dorothy comes along. It's a clever use of a very different background to tell the story, and I feel like I learned a little bit more about early twentieth century China as well, at a time when it was dominated by European, American, and Japanese imperialism. There are lots of fun little nods to both the book and The Movie, and everything turns out for the best in the end, of course. I think both of these stories were the first to truly embrace the idea suggested by the book's title, reimagining a different version of The Wizard of Oz rather than just telling a new story set in a version of Oz. Anyway, this is still a fascinating book, and I still have seven more to go, so I may finish some time over the summer.
  • I'm not sure I can exactly review The Wizard of Oz Mad Libs, just because it's not complete without folks supplying words for it. We did have some fun with it at our last Oogaboo Rendezvous, but it didn't last too long. Although it's mostly based on The Movie, the first one is a background one that talks about the book (by L. [Name of Person in the Room (Male)]). It's not to be taken terribly seriously, of course. It's just nice to have a little fun with. Incidentally, for old fuddy-duddies like me who haven't played Mad Libs for a long time, they now have a solo version built in where you can supply the words yourself, and then see how they fit, so that you don't need a whole gang of friends to enjoy this.
  • The big fiction read of the current spate of Oz reading was The Law of Oz by Paul Dana, and the first offering (of what looks like will be several) from The Royal Publisher of Oz. This book has had a long genesis, as parts were started over twenty years ago, and it shows. It's actually a series of three novellas and a short story, all starring Ojo and Button-Bright. The two friends go out seeking adventures, and Ojo persuades Button-Bright to teach him how to get lost. He does a little too well, however, and travels back in time to the enchantment of Oz! Fortunately, all goes as it should have (unlike what happened in Paradox in Oz), but through the course of events, Ojo acquires magic powers. Traveling back to their own time, Ojo is sent off to Lureline's home in the Land of An to train, while Button-Bright ends up exploring his own family background, which proves to be a lot different than anyone expected. Dana's writing matures and grows confident as the book progresses, and it all unfolds logically, but with many interesting twists. The title, incidentally, refers to Ozma's law against practicing magic, and the consequences when she tries to enforce it.
  • Then there are the comics. Surprisingly, there was only one Oz comic in this month's order, and that was issue #17 of the always awesome The Legend of Oz: The Wicked West. Glinda confronts Gale about possessing more than one of the guns of power, but it does not go well. (It seems Gale may truly be embracing her new title of Wicked Witch of the West.) Meanwhile, Dr. Pipt enlists the help of the Field Mice to destabilize the tunnels that General Jinjur is digging, but that proves to be exactly the wrong thing, and it appears that the Nome King may soon be freed. Oh, yeah, this is a good one!
  • That wasn't my only recent Oz comic, however. I recently picked up a copy of Graphic Classics Volume 15: Fantasy Classics, which includes an adaptation of "The Glass Dog", a story from L. Frank Baum's American Fairy Tales. It was a decent and faithful adaptation, and fun to see. I can't help thinking, however, that Baum wrote better short stories that may be more deserving of this treatment. The rest of the book is good, too, with the main event being an adaptation of Frankenstein, as well as works by Nathaniel Hawthorne and H. P. Lovecraft.
  • I also picked up the hardback collection of Marvel's The Emerald City of Oz, by Eric Shanower and Skottie Young. There's not much to add from my comments about the original single issue releases, but this adds a cover gallery, an introduction by Shanower, and reminiscences and farewells from Shanower and Young, as they confirm that this is their final trip to Oz, at least through Marvel.
  • And finally, a comic book I haven't even gotten yet! Zenescope was kind enough to send me a digital edition of the entire first issue of Warlord of Oz, their upcoming new OZ miniseries. While the Witches have been vanquished, their influence still lingers, and the King and his advisors (including the Scarecrow) have much to do to make Oz and its subjects happy. Meanwhile back in Kansas, Dorothy is still having dreams about Oz a year after her return. When the Scarecrow and Lion set out to find out what's happening to the Lion's people, things are starting to look bad as an ancient evil from the early history of Oz is awoken, and Dorothy and Toto find themselves transported back. This version of Oz is clearly not influenced by the books, and not even that much by The Movie, as they make up just about everything from scratch. And it must be pretty warm in this version of Oz, because those poor women barely have anything to wear! (Hmm, it might be interesting to see Zenescope's take on Jinjur and the Army of Revolt!)
  • That's all for the reading, but I have one more quick review, as I also managed to get Minnie's The Wizard of Dizz, a story from the Mickey Mouse Clubhouse series. This version of the story is clearly aimed at a lot younger viewer than me, and the computer animation is a bit crude, but it was fun. When a windstorm hits the clubhouse, Minnie and Pluto are caught outside and are whisked away to the Land of Dizz, where everyone tries to help them get home. Chip and Dale are the Chipmunchkins, Clarabelle the Cow is the rather forgetful Good Witch, Goofy is the Scarecrow (of course), Mickey is the Tin Mouse (who needs to be wound with a key, so he's a bit more like Tik-Tok than Nick Chopper), Donald is the Lion, Pete is the Wicked Witch of the West (who reforms rather than getting melted, which is probably in keeping with the very young demographics this show is aimed at), and Professor Ludwig von Drake is the Wizard. It's all fun, but probably not for everybody (including my wife, who went off to do something else after about five minutes).
That's about it for now. I don't anticipate a major Oz reading any time soon, but I suspect there will be comics here and there. I'll likely also get some new stuff that just can't wait at the Winkie Convention in August.

Saturday, January 18, 2014

The Latest Oz Reading

My, for someone who's not in his usual Oz reading cycle right now, I have quite a few books and magazines to talk about! So I guess I'd better jump in and start.

  • First up, from this months comics order, is The Steam Engines of Oz: The Geared Leviathin #1, the start of a new miniseries/story arc. Now that the Tin Woodman's heart has been restored, our heroes go in search of the Cowardly Lion. And it looks like they're going to need him, because a new threat has come to Oz over the Deadly Desert: The Wicked Witch of the West had not one, but two daughters, and they've decided it's time to end their exile!
  • The only other comic is the final issue of Marvel's The Emerald City of Oz, and also the final Oz comic from Marvel (for now, at least). After picking up the Scarecrow and Tin Woodman in the last issue, our party gathers Jack Pumpkinhead and heads home to the Emerald City, where they learn the extent of the Nome King's plans, and what Ozma intends to do about it. Of course the Scarecrow gets his clever idea and saves the day, then Glinda makes Oz invisible to the outside world. The last page is a poignant one, as L. Frank Baum receives the feather with Dorothy's message on it (and that sure looks like his gazebo at Ozcot!). I'm sad that this series has ended, but I understand why, and this is the perfect place to wrap it up. Perhaps Marvel can be convinced to continue the adaptations as graphic novels only, as I really want to see Skottie Young's take on the Patchwork Girl!
  • I also read Toto and the Cats of Oz by Robin Hess, in preparation for a quiz on this book at the last Oogaboo Rendezvous. As always, this is an awkward book for me to review, since I've known Robin for close to forty years now. I've also been familiar with this book for almost as long, as he shared bits of it at some of the earlier Oogaboo parties, back when I was still a student. It seems that Oz is under one of the greatest threats in its history, as the wizard Joom has found a way out of his imprisonment and into Oz. He uses some very dodgy magic to take over the form of a cat, and then works the cats of Oz up into a revolution. They kidnap Toto to use as a hostage in negotiations with Ozma and Dorothy, but of course he escapes and has many adventures of his own. And we get to see into some of the deepest inner workings of Glinda's magic. There are some very interesting ideas going on here, and it's a tightly plotted story, although there are times I think some of the characters use too big of a flyswatter to deal with some of the issues. It's nice to see this in print at last. (By the way, if you've never heard of Joom, you're right, he's new to this book. But he was originally planned to be another character from the Oz books who, it turns out, is still protected by copyright. If you want to know who, just spell his name backwards.)
  • And I recently realized that I've very badly fallen down on my reports on the stories in the anthology Shadows of the Emerald City. As one of my New Year's resolutions is to read an Oz short story every weekend (at least until I don't have any more to read), I think these are going to go a lot faster, but today I play catch up. First is "One Wicked Day" by Frank Dutkiewicz, which looks at what happens to the Munchkins after the Wicked Witch of the East gets squashed by a house. With such a power vacuum to fill, a new "good" witch steps in. But it seems her methods are not quite as benevolent as some others. (It is not a coincidence that her name is Leninida.)
  • "Chopper's Tale" by Jason Rubis s yet another take on the Tin Woodman's origin, as seen from the viewpoint of his axe! Yes, we see just how it was enchanted and its motivations for chopping off bits of Nick Chopper.
  • "The Perfect Fit" by E. M. MacCallum tells the story of Gayelette's half-sister, and who she became in the Oz mythos. Yes, it's another origin story. (On a side note, some day somebody has to write the definitive Gayelette story. Where has she been and what has she been doing throughout the entire Oz series?)
  • I knew that "The Fuddles of Oz" by Mari Ness would be pretty darned faithful to the books, as Ness read and reviewed all forty Oz books a few years ago for Tor's website. Sure enough, this is a tale of the Fuddles (hence the name of the story, of course) and what happens to them when the Munchkins and Gillikins find other things to do and don't come to their town as often to put them back together. This is not pretty, but it is certainly logical and goes along with everything we learned about the Fuddles in The Emerald City of Oz.
  • Speaking of short stories, I'd be remiss if I didn't also mention the 2013 issue of Oziana, the Oz Club's annual literary magazine. Unlike Shadows of the Emerald City, this year's issue is out-and-out all traditional Oz. You can see the complete rundown on my website's news page.
I have a few more non-Oz books to get through, but it looks like I'll have some more short stories and comics to report on soon, at least. Then I have some very interesting new things to share with you when the Oz reading gears up again!

Thursday, December 26, 2013

The latest Oz reading

I'm not back on my regular cycle of Oz reading at the moment, but I recently dipped into my Oz pile for a very good reason, as my Oz reread was scheduled to be Christmas in Oz by Robin Hess. (Full disclosure, Robin is a good friend of mine whom I've known for over thirty years now, and this copy was a gift — or to be more accurate, a prize for winning one of his quizzes at an Oogaboo Rendezvous.) Technically speaking, this isn't quite a reread, as this is a new, revised edition. It's not a huge epic book with lots of danger and enchantments and the like. It's just a nice quiet little slice-of-life-in-Oz book that happens to feature Santa Claus in his efforts to set up an auxiliary workshop in Oz. Chris Pedersen, a girl from Olympia, Washington, finds her way to Oz at the same time (and just wait until you read how and why it happens!) and gets wrapped up in things. Oh, and then there's Lorabie, the Wicked Blue Witch of the East, who isn't quite what she appears to be. This is a satisfying little book that's just perfect for the holiday season, and I really had a great time reading it.

Of course, I also got a big bunch of Oz comics not terribly long ago:

  • Fables #135. Yeah, yeah, Rose Red is still trying to start up her new version of the Knights of the Round Table. But for Oz fans, it's another appearance from Ozma as she is still trying to bring Bigby back to life.
  • Oz #4. Zenescope's miniseries continues with Dorothy using her powers to save Glinda, and then the flying monkeys come and take her to the Wicked Witch. The Witch, naturally, wants the Viridian Scepter for herself, and is using Dorothy to get it.
  • The Legend of Oz: The Wicked West #13. The origin story of the winged monkeys continues, including how the Wicked Witch of the West got her hands on the Golden Cap. Meanwhile, Tin Man is still trying to escape from Mombi's cottage, and it seems he may have some unexpected allies.
  • The Steam Engines of Oz #3, wrapping up the first arc. His old friends and Victoria confront the Tin Woodman, and... Well, let's just say that all's well that ends well. However, another four-issue series is set to start soon. (I also got the trade paperback collection of the first series, but I haven't had a chance to read this yet. I gather it has additional material not included in the comic books, however.)
  • And of course, last but far from least, The Emerald City of Oz #4 by Eric Shanower and Skottie Young. If you've been reading this blog for any length of time, you know my love for this book and the rest of Marvel's adaptations, so I won't go into any more detail here. I will just say that this covers Dorothy's visit to Bunnybury (in a lot fewer pages than in Baum, but nothing felt missing), Guph's report to Roquat about just which allies he's recruited to march on the Emerald City, and the party's visits to Rigmarole Town, Flutterbudget Center, the Scarecrow's new house, and the Tin Woodman's castle (yes, those last two were flipped from the order they were encountered in the book). The last two pages show the Tin Woodman delivering the bad news, which will lead to the final, concluding issue next month!
I will have one more out-of-cycle Oz book to read here very soon — but I'll tell you about that later!

Thursday, October 03, 2013

The Latest Oz Reading

Yup, there's more after all — because the latest comics order came. There aren't a lot of Oz comics in it this time, however, and one of them is Fables, which I don't think will have a lot of Oz (if any). But the first thing I read was Marvel's The Emerald City of Oz #3. As I suspected, with only five issues to tell the story, things are progressing at a breakneck pace, and the first major cut has appeared (the zebra and crab are cut — no loss there, at least). In this issue, Dorothy and her party leave the Cuttenclips, visit the Fuddles (the whole thing takes only three pages), Dorothy gets lost and visits Utensia (sadly, some of the most groan-worthy puns in the entire Oz series are cut out), and then she visits Bunbury, where we wrap up with Toto eating three crumpets and a salt-rising biscuit. Guph, meanwhile, visits the Phanfasm, and convinces them to join the Nomes and their other allies in the conquest of Oz. I like the effects Skottie Young uses to show the Phanfasms' transformations, including themselves and their whole city at the end of Guph's visit (with the old Nome being none the wiser). Again, Young and Eric Shanower have hit this one out of the park. I am looking forward to the next issue's visit to Bunnybury, and Guph's report back to Roquat.

Tuesday, September 17, 2013

Oz Comics!

We just got our most recent comics order, so you know what that means: Oz comics! Here's what came:

  • Fables #132. Ozma's still on the team trying to heal Bigby, but that's the extent of the Oz. A whole bunch of storylines are advanced in this one, and it's not looking good for a lot of our heroes. Incidentally, I found out today that both of the main guys behind Fables, Bill Willingham and Mark Buckingham, will be at the Emerald City Comicon in Seattle next spring, so I may see if I can pick their brains about the book's Oz content.
  • Oz #2 from Zenescope. Ooooookay, this is a "dark" and "edgy" version of Oz where all of the female characters are all grown up (and out) and wear as little clothing as possible. So, not your traditional Oz, then, is it? Dorothy manages to defeat the Wicked Witch of the East. Then Glinda sends her on a search for the other pieces of the Veridian Scepter (she found the handle, along with Toto, in Kansas) to restore peace in Oz and send Dorothy home. There's a big infodump about the history of this Oz, and how it ties in (loosely) with the rest of Zenescope's titles. Based on what I've seen so far, I very much doubt the writers have even bothered to rewatch The Movie, let alone read the book at all, and certainly no other Oz books enter into this version of Oz. It's kind of enjoyable in its own way, but I'm glad that this is a limited-run miniseries. On another front, I'm also glad that, if Zenescope has to go down the route of multiple covers, they at least allow you to order them all at once, and all for the same price. I managed to snag all four regular covers of this issue, as well as two covers of #1, and pre-ordered multiple covers of #3 and #4.
  • The Steam Engines of Oz Volume 1 #2. I thought the infodump in Oz was big? This issue is almost entirely infodump, giving us the back story to this Oz, and especially the Tin Woodman. The creators of Steam Engines do know their Oz, as we see the flesh-and-blood version of Nick Chopper, Nimee Amee, Ku-Klip (although not named here), and the original events of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. We even get a version of Chopfyt, but not the same as in The Tin Woodman of Oz, and the consequences of his marriage to Nimee Amee is the big difference between the Oz of the books and the events of Steam Engines. And, oh yes, things are gearing up for the big conclusion to the first arc in the next issue. But we've already ordered the first two issues of volume two, so it looks like the story will go on. Despite the major differences between the "real" Oz of the books and this one, I'm enjoying this interpretation of Oz, and I really like Victoria, our engineer protagonist. But I hope the Tin Woodman won't be such a meanie throughout the entire run, and they get him back to his regular old self soon.
  • The Legend of Oz: The Wicked West #10. Speaking of reinterpretations of Oz, here's probably my favorite one right now. Scraps has an encounter with Mombi, who gives Scraps a new pet (Bungle!). Scarecrow, Tin Man, Lion, Jack, and Tip raid Mombi's cottage, and make some discoveries about Ozma. And Jinjur and Pipt make a discovery of their own in the mines under the Emerald City. This was something of a step-back-and-take-a-breath issue, setting things up for some of the big events coming soon, possibly even in the next issue. I would never have thought a Wild West take on Oz could work, but this is an amazing book. And these guys certainly know about the Oz books. But when are Gale and Toto coming back?
  • And finally, Marvel's The Emerald City of Oz #2 (which Marvel still doesn't have on its website for some reason). The reinterpretations can be fun, but there's no place like the original Oz stories. Eric and Skottie are still hitting these out of the park, and this one's no exception. Much of the issue is Uncle Henry and Aunt Em getting used to their new home, from their new wardrobes to their first look at the ground of the palace to the start of the grand tour, ending with their meeting with the Cuttenclips. But there's another story going on here, too, as the final pages see Guph convincing the Growleywogs to join the Nomes' alliance against Oz. I'm still worried that, with only five issues, this book is going to have to leave something out, but so far, everything that I can think of is there, although perhaps a bit rushed and compressed. (Say, is that a quidditch field at Professor Wogglebug's college?) I also like how Eric has altered the structure of the story, so as to even out the Nomes' story throughout. I presume next issue we'll get Guph's encounter with the Phanfasms (and won't Skottie Young's version of them be something to look forward to?), Guph reporting back to Roquat and Ozma discovering their plan in issue four, and the march to Oz in the final issue. I'm still holding out hope that these books will continue into more of the Baum books, but if it must end here, then it's a good place to do it.

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

The Latest Oz Reading

Yup, the reading continues! Here are the rest of the Oz comics that came in the latest order:

  • The Legend of Oz: The Wicked West #9 (for which Big Dog Ink does not appear to have a link to the regular issue, just the con exclusive). Yay, Legend debut of Scraps! Everyone's getting serious about the search for Ozma now, but Jack and the Tin Man have a few issues to work out first. Oh, yeah, and the Wheelers have come after the Scarecrow. Still good stuff, this!
  • The Emerald City of Oz #1 (which Marvel doesn't seem to have any information about at all on their website). I knew there would have to be some changes in this one, as Eric, Skottie, and Jean-François only have five issues to tell this story. And sure enough (spoilers ahead, just in case you don't already know the story), the opening chapters about the Nomes are mostly compressed into the front part, from Roquat getting mad (again!) to Guph going off to talk to the Whimsies. The we cut to Kansas, and we see Dorothy get the bad news about the farm, her transportation to Oz (and unlike in the original novel, this time we see her take Eureka as well), bring Aunt Em and Uncle Henry in, and the latter two deciding to accept the fate that's been handed to them. The book wraps up with Guph convincing the Whimsies to help the Nomes conquer Oz. As I suspected, the storytelling feels a little rushed, but so far everything is there, at least. I think the only new thing Skottie Young adds to this book is the Whimsies, who look great. The cross-section showing their true heads inside the pasteboard false ones is a nice touch. And yes, yet again everyone does a bang-up job.
  • Not Oz, strictly speaking, but certainly of interest to many Oz fans is Age of Bronze #33. The saga of Troilus and Cressida continues, as Diomedes tries to woo Cressida, while Troilus waits for her every night by the gates of Troy. Something tells me this is not going to end well! Also announced in this issue is the forthcoming publication of the next collection, part 2 of the Betrayal storyline.
Speaking of Eric Shanower, I picked up two of the hardback collections of the Marvel comics a few months ago, and the third at the Winkie Convention, where I also got them all signed (with bonus illustrations!) by Eric. So now I have Ozma of Oz, Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz, and The Road to Oz, and I'm up to date. I hope Skottie Young is at Emerald City Comic Con again next year so I can get them signed by him as well. Anyway, each of these collections includes an informative introduction by Eric, a cover gallery, and in many cases some of Skottie's development sketches. Two more items before I wrap up:
  • The Program Book to this year's Winkie Convention. This is always a treat, and they just seem to get bigger and better every year. This year's book highlights The Patchwork Girl of Oz, which turns one hundred this year, and Merry Go Round in Oz, which is still a sprightly fifty years. I have no idea if any copies are still available, but if they are, I bet David Maxine could be persuaded to part with one for a donation to the convention. If you want to get your hands on next year's edition, here's the information on next year's convention. It's never too late to start planning! (Note to the convention organizers: How about supporting memberships, for those who can't actually be there but want to be a part of the fun anyway? The big incentive for those people would be the program book, and possibly a few other little goodies.)
  • Oz the Great and Powerful: The Movie Storybook. Yeesh, and I thought the Junior Novelization was slight. Still, for the audience they're aiming at, this isn't bad. The best part about the storybook is the large colorful pictures, taken right from the movie. There is a definite lack of conversation, however, with major dialogue covered by a few sentences instead. Still, they are writing for a younger audience that they may think can't handle a lot of talking.
Next up are some classic rereadings, inspired by Oz the Great and Powerful.

Saturday, April 20, 2013

The Latest Oz Reading

Yup, time for another post to catch you up on all the Oz stuff I've been reading lately. It's mostly comics this time. I hope you don't mind.

  • The Road to Oz #6 by Eric Shanower and Skottie Young. Yup, it's over. This one starts with the Scarecrow's arrival (abbreviated a bit from the book) to, well, the end of the book, of course. Dorothy gets the honor of greeting the guests, and yet again, Skottie Young doesn't disappoint. He gets the chance to illustrate such characters as John Dough, Chick the Cherub, Para Bruin, the Queen of Merryland and the Candy Man, Queen Zixi (looking very exotic), King Bud and Princess Fluff, and Santa Claus, of course. (I'll be interested to see if there's an afterword in the trade collection explaining who all these people are!) Naturally, he goes to town. Because of the shortened page run for this book, Ozma's birthday parade and the appearance of the Good Witch of the North are cut out. This does not bode well for The Emerald City of Oz, which will be limited to only five issues! Yikes!
  • Fables #127 by Bill Willingham, Mark Buckingham, Steve Leialoha, and Andrew Pepoy. Snow white is still under a nasty spell, so of course the rest of the Fables are trying to save her. This includes all of the most powerful magic users in town. This includes Ozma! She hasn't appeared for a while. Sadly, she isn't able to help much.
  • The Legend of Oz: The Wicked West ongoing #5 by Tom Hutchison, Alisson Borges, and Kate Finnegan. We now know who the guy is with the hatchet and the orange face mask: It's Jack Pumpkinhead, of course. He shows up at Glinda's mansion, demanding to have an audience with her or he'll start breaking off Tip's fingers. But he won't do that, as he and Tip are old accomplices; it was all a ruse so that he could see her quickly. It turns out he has some information for her — which we won't hear about until the next issue, of course! Also, we get some flashbacks to Jinjur's life, and how events helped to make her the woman she is today. I'm still enjoying this series, and I'm interested in seeing where it goes. And I'm already thinking about the possibility of cosplaying Jack some day.
  • Not part of the regular comics order, but a comic nevertheless, is the large Treasury edition of The Forgotten Forest of Oz by Eric Shanower. This was reprinted a few years ago by IDW in a nice, large edition. When Hungry Tiger Books announced they were sold out, I figured I'd better jump on it, and get it elsewhere. Sadly, IDW was also sold out, but I did manage to find a single used copy online, and snagged it even though money's a bit tight right now. Yup, this is still as good a story as it was when it was first published back in the '80s, but the larger size and clearer images suits it well. I would hope IDW would go back and reprint the rest of Eric's Oz graphic novels in this format, but I have a sneaking suspicion that that won't happen.
  • My one non-comic reading was my reread for this cycle, Was by Geoff Ryman. I was not happy when I first read this book, over twenty years ago. It seemed to take all the fun and joy out of Oz and made it dark and twisted, and it really, really tuned me off. However, in the ensuing years, I've heard so much praise heaped on this book that I wondered what was going on. Finally, the folks over at the SF Squeecast (two of whom I now know personally) started talking about it, and so I decided to give it another shot. Could twenty years of maturation give me new insights to this book? Well, I read it, and I don't think I can say that I hate this book any more. However, I'm still not sure that I can say I like it, either. The premise, of the connections from Dorothy growing up in Kansas, meeting L. Frank Baum who wrote a story about her, to Dorothy dying in a Kansas sanitarium, to one of the attendants there becoming the doctor of an AIDS patient in the '80s, is actually pretty good, and well put together. It all comes full-circle when Jonathan, the AIDS patient, decides to find just where Dorothy lived. The scenes of young Jonathan dreaming himself into the first television broadcast of The Wizard of Oz are still the best thing about the book, but now on this read I'm more confused by the inclusion of vignettes with Judy Garland during production of the movie, and her mother's death, as they are not really connected to much else in the book. I think I can better admire what Ryman was trying to do in this story, and it's a much better book if you don't think of it as an Oz book. But I still can't accept Uncle Henry, in any manifestation, being a child molester.
No new comics yet, so I get a bit of a break there. I have a short stack of other books to finish up (including another Rachel Cosgrove Payes romance), and then I'll tell you all about them then.

Saturday, February 09, 2013

The Latest Oz Reading

The new comics order came the other day. And you know what that means, don't you? That's right, new Oz comics! The first thing I read was Marvel's The Road to Oz #4. Yup, still good! This issue covers the escape from the Scoodlers through to the gang's meeting with Tik-Tok and Billina and the arrival at the Tin Woodman's new palace. So about the only new thing in here was Johnny Dooit. He looks pretty impressive (the little bowler hat was a nice touch), but what really suckered me in was his toolbox. Wow, Skottie Young really went to town on that!

Tuesday, January 01, 2013

The Latest Oz Reading

Welcome to 2013! Hmm, it doesn't look that different from 2012 yet, does it? And speaking of 2012, I have a little catching up to do, with some unfinished business. I'm not in the midst of my usual cycle of Oz reading, but there were comics last month! So, here they are:

  • Fables #123. Bigby saves the day, yadda yadda, let's get to Oz! A Revolution in Oz is wrapping up, as Ruggedo has an encounter with a piece of rope. Next issue promises to be good, as it wraps up this storyline — and that's all in it!
  • The Legend of Oz: The Wicked West #2. Tip rescues the Scarecrow, and meets up with the Sawhorse (but not after the latter has an encounter with the Field Mice). Jinjur enlists the Wheelers' help in getting them back. And there's a horse named Chittenango!
  • The Oz/Wonderland Chronicles: Prelude to Evil #2. The biggest problem with these books is that they come out so far apart and irregularly that it's really hard to keep up with the storyline. But there is one iconic scene in this book: The Frogman meets the Frog Footman from Alice in Wonderland! How cool is that? (Glinda also looks terrific in this book.)
  • And finally, The Road to Oz #3. Still going strong! Shaggy gets a new head. King Kik-a-Bray looks particularly silly in his glasses (a detail I don't recall from Baum, but used by both Neill and Young). The Musicker! (I love what Skottie Young does for his teeth!) And at long last, Skottie Young gets to show us his Scoodlers! Surprisingly, this may be one creature he sticks closest to Neill with — and yet they're very Youngesque and definitely creepy. Of course, the Queen is even worse! This issue wraps up with Polychrome slapping their guard, so we'll see what happens in the next issue (which I should be getting soon). I can definitely tell that there are some details from the book that Eric Shanower would have included in earlier books, but with the new six-issue limit, some of it had to go. The good news is that it still feels like it's there, and little actual content has been jettisoned, even though the pace is a little quicker.
Since I'm on my winter break right now, I'm also trying to tackle a few of the stories from the anthology Shadows of the Emerald City. I've always felt that there was a lot of untapped potential for Oz short stories, and this sort of anthology could be a big success. However, Shadows has a definite dark turn to it that is not going to appeal to a lot of hardcore Oz book fans, even though there are a lot of homages to the books in here. Even Pigasus turns up! But it's also clear that most of the contributors know a lot more about Oz from The Movie than the books, as a lot of the imagery is more MGM than Baum, and many create character backgrounds or Oz histories out of whole cloth, not based on anything Baum wrote. So, here are the ones I've read over the past couple of weeks:
  • "Tin" by Barry Napier. An alternate origin for the Tin Woodman, one in which he's a spy for the Wicked Witch! This one does not turn out well, and is clearly set in an alternate version of Oz.
  • "Fly, Fly Pretty Monkey" by Camille Alexa. The Wicked Witch of the West shows her maternal side towards the monkeys. There's an alternate explanation for the purpose of the Golden Cap in this one.
  • "A Heart Is Judged" by Kevin G. Summers. The Wicked Witch of the East has a diabolical plan to keep the Munchkins in line (with some shades of The Hunger Games). There's a neat little twist ending to one of the characters in this one, and we also get an origin for the Scarecrow that at least makes more sense than the one in The Royal Book of Oz.
  • "Mr. Yoop's Soup" by Michael D. Turner. Mr. Yoop has escaped, and comes to the Munchkin Country for his first proper meal in years. This is definitely the most gruesome, and at the same time funniest, story in the collection so far. Do not eat this one while eating, or on a full stomach!
  • "Emerald City Confidential" by Jack Bates. A noir-influenced tale of power and corruption, as an exiled member of Ozma's security force comes back from exile to try to find out who is wiping out Munchkins. But he quickly finds he is in over his head.
  • And finally (for now), "The Last Battle of Trewis" by David S. Mason. An old soldier from the last revolution comes face to face with the former emperor of Oz — the one Trewis killed during the war!

Friday, November 23, 2012

The Latest Oz Reading

I've done a real blitz on the comics recently, and managed to get through all the rest of them from last month and all of this month's as well! So yes, lots of Oz comics to review! Let's jump right in with the remainder of last month's:

  • Dorothy of Oz Prequel #4, the concluding issue. The Scarecrow, Tin Woodman, and Cowardly Lion finally get to the Rainbow Mover and use it to summon Dorothy — whom we finally get to see in this comic! It looks like she's already dealing with a lot of her own problems, however. Glinda has some issues to deal with as well! It will be interesting to see how this comic series leads into the movie when it comes out next year (and we still have no clear idea when; I suspect it won't be until late summer, so as not to compete with Oz: The Great and Powerful.)
  • Fables #121. Yeah, yeah, problems in Toyland, Therese and Dare are still there... Meanwhile, in Oz, the flying monkeys are using guerilla (heh!) tactics to make things difficult for the Nome King's soldiers as the rebellion continues.
  • The Road to Oz #2. Eric and Skottie are still hitting this one out of the park. This issue takes us from the entry into Foxville to their arrival at Dunkiton. The only major new introduction is Polychrome, and she is very different from what I suspect anyone was expecting, as she has a much more otherwordly, ethereal look than how I've ever seen her illustrated before. This makes sense, however, when you consider what a rainbow is and how it's really constructed. The big difference is that not only her dress, but also her hair is rainbow patterned. It may take some getting used to, but it at least makes some sense.
Now for the comics from this month's order:
  • No Place Like Home #5, the concluding issue to the initial miniseries version of this comic. Until now, I'll admit to being underwhelmed by this book, as it just didn't seem very Ozzy. There have been lots of little sideways references to Oz characters and events, and the killer flying monkeys have naturally been a big selling point, but the Oz just seemed tacked on. (It does not help that Dee, Lizzie, and most of the rest of the characters are just plain foul mouthed!) But all that changes here, with the reveal of who's been pulling the strings on the final page — and the promise that the story will continue soon with the start of volume 2!
  • Fables #122. A new arc, looking back at some of the Big Bad Wolf's exploits in the Fable Lands, starts in this issue. But who cares when there's still a rebellion going on in Oz? All I have to say about this is, Mr. Yoop shows up and starts making things really difficult for the Nome King's lackeys.
  • The Legend of Oz: The Wicked West Ongoing Series #1 (the regular issue appears to be sold out at the publishers, so that link is to the less expensive (!) of their variant edition). Gale and the Wizard are gone, but life goes on in Oz without them. In a power vacuum, the Wizard's old assistant, Jinjur, has taken control and given herself the title of General, and she's keeping the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Lion locked up. But hope comes in the unexpected form of a boy named Tip.
Okay, so despite how it first looked, both No Place Like Home and The Legend of Oz will continue. Neat!

And that's probably going to be it for a little while with the Oz reading, as I'm now in a cycle of reading other things (yes, believe it or not, there's a whole wide world of other things to read out there).

One more word, if I may: I've been revamping my website's bookshop all summer, and it's now finally all ready to unveil to the world. I think the wiki format gives it a cleaner, less cluttered look, and it will also make it a lot easier for me to update. So please feel free to go on over to the bookshop and take a look around. (If you buy anything, even better!)

Sunday, November 04, 2012

The Latest Oz Reading

I have been very busy lately. Fortunately for me, that's because I have a new job. (And did the first quarter already just end? My, how time flies when you're busy!) However, that also means I've had less time to either read Oz books or blog about them. But the end of Daylight Saving Time gives me an extra hour today, so I thought I'd do some badly needed catch-up work. Besides, I've just finished my latest spate of Oz reading, and figured I'd better write about these books before I forget all about them.

  • First up is the last of last month's Oz comics. The Legend of Oz: The Wicked West #4 wraps up the retelling of The Wizard of Oz set in the Old West with — what else? — a big gunfight between Gale and the Wicked Witch. But Gale does not finally make it home. Instead, she's gained a new title. This is the final issue of the miniseries, but the story continues in the forthcoming ongoing series, for which there is a preview at the end of this issue. Since some of the new characters include Jack Pumpkinhead, Tippetarius, and the Wheelers, it looks like the creators are tapping the rest of the Baum Oz books.
  • I've had a .pdf file of Shadows of the Emerald City to review for some time now, and it's finally bubbled up to the top of my list. As this is a collection of Oz/horror short stories, I'm reading it two at a time, rather than all at once, so I guess I'd better review each story as I read them. First up was "Dr. Will Price and the Curious Case of Dorothy Gale" by Mark Onspaugh, in which a psychiatrist, fascinated by the case of a Kansas girl who went insane after having gone missing for some time, meets Dorothy, now an old woman in an asylum, and tries to find out more about her. He decides to take her out to her aunt and uncle's old farmstead to see what kinds of memories will arise, only to find himself in Oz! Let's just say Oz is not as kind to outsiders as it was when Dorothy came. The second story, "Pumpkinhead" by Rajan Khanna, sees the latest visitor from the Outside World meeting Jack Pumpkinhead, and the troubles that result from some of the awkward questions she asks him about his old heads. This is not my usual kind of reading, but so far, these stories have been fascinating. These writers clearly know their Oz, as both stories talk about aspects of the later books (the first story even names the Good Witch of the North Locasta!). But these are also clearly looking-glass versions of Oz, very much written for more mature readers than anything Baum intended. There are a lot of Oz fans who will not want to read this book, but if you are a more brad-minded reader, you may very well find something in this book to enjoy.
  • Tales Told in Oz by Gregory Maguire is exactly what the title says: A collection of tales told in Maguire's version of Oz, as seen in his Wicked books. Think of this as the Ozian equivalent of The Tales of Beedle the Bard in the Harry Potter world. It's slim, a fast read, and a must have for Wicked fans. Others may want to take a pass. However, the book is also inexpensive, and proceeds go to benefit the Friends of the West Hartford Library, so that's a win-win situation.
  • When I was a very young Oz fan, and there weren't so many Oz books to collect, I managed to get a number of titles from the Pamami Press, run by another young Oz fan, Michael O. Riley. These were small, limited press editions printed by hand, of short stories and essays by L. Frank Baum. Now that we're both a lot older, I'm happy to report that Riley has started Pamami Press up again, and his first new offering for sale in the twenty-first century is Fairy Tales on the Stage. In this article, first published in the run-up to the debut of The Woggle-Bug (his dramatization of The Marvelous Land of Oz), Baum discusses the evolution of how fairy tales have been presented on the stage (er, pretty obvious from that title, actually). Riley slips in a few pages from an aborted earlier edition of this book that he tried to publish in 1985.
  • My Rachel Cosgrove Payes novel this time around is Love's Charade. Yes, back to the romances. In fact, this is the first of a five-volume series about the seven Lassiter sisters, whose classical father named them all after the Pleiades! He's not wealthy, but wants to make sure that they marry well, so his childless sister-in-law offers to introduce them to proper London society. Naturally, they want the oldest daughter, Alcyone (Allie for short — thank goodness most of them have sensible nicknames), to be first, but she's shy and reluctant, and refuses to spend the season in London, so the more outgoing Merrie (short for Merope) gets to go. She's quite smitten with a young Irish lord, Beau Fallon, but as the second son, he doesn't have any money, and is looking for a rich wife so that he can buy his own estate and farm. The usual hijinks and misunderstandings ensue, and it naturally all works out in the end, and not without a few twists. Overall, a satisfying but fluffy little read. What surprised me the most is how tame this one was. Unlike the other romances I've read by Rachel, there were no scenes of bodice-ripping, if you know what I mean. What makes this especially astonishing is that this book was published by Playboy Paperbacks!
  • Fables: Animal Farm is the second collection of the Fables comic book series, and deals with the farm in upstate New York where the non-human Fables live — or, as some of them see it, imprisoned. Snow White takes Rose Red up there to work off some of her punishment (after the events of the first book), only to find herself in the middle of a rebellion. It all works out well in the end, but not before a few fences are torn down. Not a lot of Oz in this one, either, but Bufkin makes a few appearances.
  • I got a double dose of books reread this time around. First was Dorothy of Oz by Roger S. Baum, which I wanted to reread before the movie comes out. (I've had it in my to-read pile for some time, and hoped to red it a lot sooner, but the delay in the movie's release made me not want to read it too soon). I've never been a big fan of Roger Baum's books, because he doesn't seem to realize that there are other books outside of The Wizard of Oz — either that, or he's writing to an audience that he thinks can only handle books related to The Movie. However, Dorothy of Oz has a lot less of this problem, at least. It seems to be set somewhere between Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz and The Emerald City of Oz, since the Wizard is back in Oz and Ozma's on the throne, but Dorothy isn't living in Oz yet. But I think I've pinpointed what bugged me about this book when it first came out, and still does: The lack of conversation. Baum spends too much time writing descriptions about what people are saying when it could just as easily be handled with the characters actually talking to each other. Beyond that, it was a pretty straightforward, if not terribly exciting or original, adventure in Oz. And hey, I've already found one big difference between the book and the movie: In the book, the Jester is not the Wicked Witch of the West's brother!
  • The other reread was Masquerade in Oz by Bill Campbell and Irwin Terry. I wanted to reread this for Halloween anyway. When I received an extra copy as my prize for winning the quiz at the Winkie Convention, I figured that was a sign to really dig in. Betsy Bobbin's birthday is coming up, and since her birthday is October 31, she wants to have a masquerade party. So all of her Oz friends decide to dress up as each other! Being the birthday girl, Betsy gets to be Ozma. Ozma, meanwhile, dresses as Jellia Jamb. The Scarecrow dresses as the Tin Woodman, Nick Chopper becomes Jack Pumpkinhead, Dorothy becomes Scraps, Tik-Tok becomes Cap'n Bill, and so forth. It's all a lot of fun, and only Scraps decides not to take part. Good thing, too, because when Scraps starts playing around with some of the Wizard's magic, everyone else believes that they really are who they're disguised as. Yes, Chaos ensues, and Scraps is the only one who can straighten out her mess, since she's still herself. She gets to visit all kinds of nooks and crannies of the royal palace looking for a way to fix things. She does, of course, but not before a lot of mischief is made.
  • I wasn't at all sure what Aligned Yellow Bricks: The Road Back to Kansas by Bob Woodward was about when I bought it, and was surprised to find that it was another Oz-themed book about business and how to make it better. Hmm, okay, I thought as I kept reading, not the first of these I've read. The fun part turned out to be later in the book, when Woodward sets up a pretend company to demonstrate how his ideas work. The executives who work for the Professor Marvel Manufacturing Plant have some very familiar or evocative names, like Howard Lee Lyon, Noah Hart, Glenn Duwich, and N. Todd Ohtu (say it out loud to get the connection). The General Manager? Grayton Powell Falloz, of course. Each chapter is also headed with a quote from The Movie, although connecting the quote to the main topic of the chapter is sometimes a really long stretch.
  • Dorothy: The Darker Side of Oz by Scott Stanford is a loose retelling of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz in a Lovecraftian horror-themed version of Oz. This is not a book that we needed, as there are already all kinds of dark reinterpretations of Oz out there. Still, this one had a couple of interesting twists, like the Wicked Witch's final (or was it?) fate, and the Scarecrow always having to remind himself who people were, because otherwise he'd forget. But like so many self-published books, this is a book in serious need of an editor. Dorothy continuously referred to as a "young girl" even though she's eighteen. The author uses "your" a lot when he means "you're", and the word for falling back is "recede", not "reseed". I also think about a third of the book could be cut without losing much, particularly in the beginning. Descriptions kept going on longer than needed, and he uses a lot of the same ones repeatedly when some variety would have helped. Purists should stay away from this one, as should those with a low tolerance for a lack of editing.
  • And finally, the next comic order came while I was still working on the last one, so I have a few Oz issues coming up. But I had to jump in and read The Road to Oz #1. As usual, Eric and Skottie are in fine form, and I have no complaints. This issue covers Dorothy meeting the Shaggy Man (of course) to the arrival in Foxville, but they haven't met the King yet. First, I like how Skottie Young is handling Dorothy over the series. She looks a little older now (which makes sense), and her hair is in a different, simpler style here. The Shaggy Man looks pretty unkempt. Button-Bright doesn't look quite as pretty as he does in the book, which is probably a good thing. I wasn't sure about snow on the approach to Foxville, but it made sense when the foxes came out dressed like Soviet soldiers, complete with fur hats! Genius! I look forward to the rest of the series, especially how Young handles Polychrome next issue.
Except for a few comics, that's about it for now. I'm not sure when I'll be able to get back to such a long list of Oz reading, but it will verylikely include more Fables, another Lassiter sister looking for a husband, a newly reprinted Denslow classic, and other surprises.

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Dorothy's there, but not Bob or Bing

Things are gearing up for the big release of The Road to Oz from Marvel. They've just released Eric Shanower's variant cover for issue #1 — and here it is!

Friday, July 13, 2012

The Latest Oz Comics Book Reading

And so we come to the end of Marvel's adaptation of Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz with issue #8. This one should be subtitled "The Trial of Eureka the Kitten", for that's pretty much it, with everyone going home in the last few pages. A pretty straightforward adaptation of the incident, with Eric Shanower cleverly slipping some of Baum's descriptions into dialogue said by the people of the Emerald City. The big star here is Skottie Young (yes, again), as he illustrates some things we've never seen before, like Ozma and Dorothy's rooms. I also really liked the Wogglebug's oversized powdered wig as prosecutor, and his growing frustration at the many interruptions to his accusatory speech. I know there are some Oz fans out there who don't like Young's interpretation of Oz, but I suspect in many cases it's just because he's not slavishly imitating John R. Neill — although I seem to recall taking a little while to warm up to his style at first myself, so maybe I'm projecting. Anyway, that one's done, and then we have a few months wait until The Road to Oz kicks off. Just think, Skottie Young doing the Scoodlers, and Polychrome, and Johnny Dooit, and all those guests at Ozma's birthday! This one will be fun!

Monday, June 25, 2012

The latest Oz reading

I read more Oz comics last night. So:

  • Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz #7 (which, for some reason, Marvel doesn't appear to have anywhere on its website). See my comments on #6 yesterday. They're pretty much the same. This issue goes from Dorothy's old friends coming to greet her and the Wizard, and ends with Jim's race against the Sawhorse.
  • No Place Like Home. #4. Man, those girls have some potty mouths on them! Yeah, this is clearly a horror comic for adults, and if there was no Oz connection, there's no way I'd be getting it. As it is, the Oz connection is pretty weak, other than there's a big angry flying monkey causing all kinds of trouble. But there are also lots of little nods to Oz, in many forms. One of the supporting characters is named Frank, there's a dog named Terry, a grave marker has "Gumm", and there's a picture of a pair of feet sticking out from under a dollhouse that should look familiar. Oh, yeah, and one character wears a Pink Floyd "Dark Side of the Moon" t-shirt. One more issue to go of the current storyline, but the writers are now promising that there will be more. Let's see if the Oz content can be ratcheted up a bit.
  • Fables #117. Yeah, Therese is missing and finding out that being queen of the lost toys isn't all it's cracked up to be, and Dare and Bigby are out looking for her. But what about the revolt in Oz? It's been called off! But why? Jack Pumpkinhead and the Nomes are pretty amusing in this one.
I'm working on one more item from this latest Oz reading jag, but that's it for the comics this month. But don't worry! There will be more soon, I'm sure! And in case you haven't already heard, Marvel is already putting out publicity for their adaptation of The Road to Oz. SQUEE!!!

Sunday, June 24, 2012

The latest Oz reading

I have been tearing through a number of Oz and related books and other readings lately, so I figure I'd better get going and tell you all about them!

  • The 2012 edition of Oziana, the literary magazine of the International Wizard of Oz Club (which doesn't actually appear to be for sale anywhere yet). Time for a little disclosure here: I'm now a Contributing Editor to Oziana. This pretty much means that I get an early draft and check it over for spelling, grammar, and punctuation errors. I don't see it as a big deal, but Marcus, the editor, thinks it is, and lists me on the masthead and even asks me to sign bookplates for the premium collector copies. Whatever. So I've read this one before, but as I was going over it with a fine-toothed comb looking for errors, I wasn't actually paying as much attention to the story. This time around, I got to read it for fun. In something of a departure, it's all one unified story with several contributors. The fun part is that it starts off with a fragment from L. Frank Baum! (Well, it turns out, thanks to the background given by Robert A. Baum in his introduction, that it may not have been L. Frank who wrote it. But it's been floating around for years, always attributed to Baum, and we don't have any idea who actually wrote it.) Then each subsequent section was written by another writer, and passed on to the next, until it was getting to the right length and could be wrapped up by the final contributor. It was a fun little story, but as is often the nature of these tales, it goes off in several directions, and it was up to Atticus Gannaway to wrap it up and give it a satisfying conclusion. I want to give a shout-out to S. P. Maldonado, who did the pictures, and a mighty nice job, too. I especially liked his illustration of Ozma in her ice skating outfit.
  • The Magical Monarch of Mo by L. Frank Baum. This was my classic reread, but not quite how you might expect. I started reading this to my nephew when he came over for a visit last summer. I figured short stories would be perfect, and these fit the bill nicely. About the same time, I was wrapping up my own reading of The Collected Short Stories of L. Frank Baum, and since the Mo stories weren't in that collection, I decided to just keep going and finish Mo after I didn't have to read it to anyone else. I really enjoyed this book when I was a kid, and I still do on that level, but I can also see a lot more of the absurdity and pseudo-horror in this book now that I'm an adult. Still, it was a fun read. (Now could someone give us an inexpensive reprint of the original version of this book, A New Wonderland?)
  • Continuing on with the short stories, I picked up the new Dover edition of Little Wizard Stories of Oz. As always, Dover does a great job, and despite this being a paperback, this edition has two pluses over other recent reprint editions: (1) The text and line art are printed in blue ink, as in the first edition (not so easy on the eyes, but not too bad, either); (2) An introduction by the late Martin Gardner. It doesn't give a lot of insight, and he barely discusses the stories at all, but it's a nice little addition.
  • The Fate of a Crown by "Schuyler Staunton", AKA L. Frank Baum. This is an adventure novel Baum wrote under a pen name, and it was the last of Baum's pseudonymous books that I hadn't read. So I was very happy to see this reprint edition. I was especially eager to get it when I found out that, besides the book's original illustrations by Glen C. Sheffer, it included those from the original newspaper serialization of the story. The publishers of this edition couldn't identify that artist, but his name is John R. Neill! His familiar signature is even clearly visible in many of the pictures, so someone just plain didn't do their research. Ah, but what about the story itself? It's definitely a potboiler, as young American clerk Robert Harcliffe is sent to Brazil to assist a client, who turns out to be one of the ringleaders in the revolution against Emperor Dom Pedro II. Of course Robert gets swept up in local politics, and even meets the Emperor himself before he is deposed. It's all terribly melodramatic, with secret loves and secret vaults and betrayals and the like. A few years ago, my friend Judy Bieber, an expert in Latin American history, wrote an article for The Baum Bugle about the real history and people behind this book, so now that I've finally read the book, I'm looking forward to digging that up and reading it again.
  • The Man with Three Eyes by "E. L. Arch", AKA Rachel Cosgrove Payes. I needed a break from Rachel's historical romances (and I have plenty more to keep me occupied for a while), and this proved to be just what I needed. This is a science fiction novel from 1967, in which a comedic third eye that sticks to your forehead with a suction cup proves to be something far more sinister, and the diverse residents of a New York City boarding house become involved in an alien invasion plot. It reads like a middle-of-the-road episode of The Twilight Zone or some B-movie of the era, and some of the attitudes towards women and minorities have not aged well, but it was definitely an entertaining read. Part of the invasion involves some Venus flytrap-like plants that scoop up and eat animals, and I couldn't help wondering if the similar plants from The Patchwork Girl of Oz might have influenced Rachel.
  • Since I've started reading the Fables comic book series, Laura and I decided to go back and read the series from the beginning via the trade paperbacks. I've now read the first volume, Legends in Exile, and it is a great set-up of the situation and some of the major players. But the only Oz content is a flying monkey seen around Snow White's office (I presume this is Bufkin). So, moving on...
  • Toto's Tale by K. D. Hays and Meg Weidman retells The Wizard of Oz from Toto's point of view. This is closer to the book version than the movie, but it's not quite the same, either (the Scarecrow doesn't get stuck in the river, no trip south, new creatures that the Wicked Witch of the West has enslaved). Since Toto interacts with his environment through his nose, we learn what an awful lot of things smell like, and he doesn't always understand what the other characters are saying, either. It makes for a fun telling of the story. I do wish there were more of April Martinez's illustrations, because they are charming and original.
  • At long last, the ninth and concluding volume of Michael Buckley's Sisters Grimm series, The Council of Mirrors! This one feels like it's been too long in coming, but it was worth the wait. I hadn't really figured it out until this book, but the whole series has been about Sabrina, the older of the two girls. She's been at the center of most of the action, more than her younger sister Daphne, and here she firmly takes center stage. She's no longer reacting to events, but taking charge, despite all of her reservations and hesitations. I won't say any more, except that it ends on a surprising but satisfying conclusion. There's not a lot of Oz content, but several Oz characters appear, and the Scarecrow, Cowardly Lion, and Tik-Tok all have big parts to play. We even get what I think are the Sisters Grimm debuts of Scraps and Bungle.
  • Of course the comics also arrived, and there were a lot of Oz titles. I had to jump in first with Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz #6, since there wasn't an issue last month. So, real quick, Eric and Skottie do another bang-up job, it all looks good, blah blah blah. This issue starts with the party's conversation with the Dragonettes, and ends with the arrival in Oz, and the Wizard telling Ozma his history (ooh, flashbacks!) and being invited to stay. And there are still two issues to go!
  • And finally (for now), Dorothy of Oz Prequel #2. The Scarecrow, Tin Woodman, and Lion have hatched the plan to bring Dorothy back to Oz, and the Dainty China Country is shaken up by an earhquake conjured up by the Jester. Oh, yeah, and there's a run-in with the Gamekeeper, and Marshall Mallow is in the teaser for the next issue.
This isn't the end of my current Oz reading, but that's certainly the bulk of it. There are at least a few more comics coming soon.

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Coming to a comic shop near you...

Marvel just put out their latest solicits today, for comics coming out in September. Oz fans will want to take a look at this one. Yes, that's the cover for issue #1 of The Road to Oz. Woo-hoo! I have a sneaking suspicion that Road may work very well in comic book form, because of all of the little incidents that take place. Each issue should wrap up very nicely, but with a little preview of the next adventure.

Sunday, March 25, 2012

The Latest Oz Reading (and Watching)

Despite the lack of posts, I have been busy reading a bunch of Oz things. In fact, I'm just about done with one of the longer ones — bu I'll tell you more about that later. So here are a few other things I've read and watched lately:


  • Bride of Fury by Rachel Cosgrove Payes. My latest reading from the author of The Hidden Valley of Oz. This one reminded me an awful lot of the last Rachel romance I read, in that it has a lusty young woman torn between two men from the same family (brothers, this time) in a historical setting, etc., etc., etc. I'm sure many of you are familiar with some of the tropes of the genre. What makes Bride of Fury fun, however, is that it opens with our heroine, Kate, patrolling the West End of London looking for Jack the Ripper! The rest of the book then flashes back to how Kate got into the situation she's in, and comes to a satisfying conclusion for both her and the reader. Rachel sets up the mystery of who Jack the Ripper is well throughout the book, and leaves everyone dangling until the last possible moment. I enjoyed it, but I think I'm already a little weary of her romances. Thank goodness the next book I have lined up from her is something different!
  • The comics order came, need I say more? And it was a busy month. First was Grimm Fairy Tales Presents The Library #4. Things are looking pretty bad, which of course forces Sela's father to reexamine his life and finally connect with his daughter. But the Wicked Witch is overpowering every ally Sela can throw at her, and it looks like the Wicked Witch now has the power to take over the world! (Good thing there's one more issue to this series, or I'd be worried.)
  • Fables #114. Yay, back to Oz at last! No, we don't learn how Bufkin escaped from that cliffhanger. In fact, it looks like we've gone back a few days, before the events of #101. The good news is, now the Oz part of the story looks like it will be a permanent part of the book, at least for a while, as "A Revolution in Oz" is now the second story of the book. Did I also mention that someone pilfered the vault containing all of the magic items in Oz?
  • Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz #5. The Gargoyles. Need I say more? Again, Eric, Skottie, and Jean-Francois have put together another winner. Sadly, it will have to hold me for a while, since issue #6 isn't due out until May.
  • No Place Like Home #1. Where have I seen this before? A grown-up goth Dorothy (is she?) gets caught up in events that may or may not be at all related to The Wizard of Oz. This one is aiming to be a horror comic, as Dee Dee and her friends stumble across a murder. I'm not sure where this one's going at all yet, but it's early. Definitely not one for the kids, Oz purists, or sensitive readers.
  • And finally, I watched the second part of The Witches of Oz a few weeks ago, and just forgot to tell anyone. It's definitely not one for the purists again, but it's fun and Ozzy in its own way. Dorothy confronts her past, and finds both friends and foes coming to New York City to get something they all think Dorothy has. This was definitely based on the first Oz book, but there were plenty of nods to later Oz books that you know the creators did their homework. I was especially taken with Mia Sara's portrayal of Langwidere. I just hope the film version comes to my neck of the woods sometime soon.

Tuesday, January 31, 2012

The latest Oz reading

I've gotten through the latest comics. Here are the Oz contents:


  • Grimm Fairy Tales Presents the Library #3. The Wicked Witch of the West manages to get the key, only for Sela to then steal the book from her and escape into another story, with lots of rain, a very haunted-looking house, and someone else who wants the key and book, too!
  • Fables #112. Wait, you end the last issue on that cliffhanger, and then don't even touch it this issue? Which means no Oz content at all? Moving on...
  • Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz #4. We're halfway done with this one! This issue covers the Valley of Voe (wow, that's one mean looking bear!) and the Braided Man. As usual, a terrific adaptation by Eric Shanower and wonderful new art by Skottie Young.

I also acquired a new book, The Illustrated Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. I got this one because it includes John R. Neill's illustrations from the 1908 Reilly & Britton edition of Alice. Unfortunately, this volume only reproduces six of Neill's pictures, and all but one within the first two dozen or so pages. (It probably comes as no surprise that Neill's Alice looks an awful lot like his Dorothy.) Despite that, it's a nice if not spectacular edition of Alice, with the original John Tenniel illustrations, and others by Arthur Rackham, Gordon Robinson, Harry Rountree, and even Lewis Carroll himself.

Sunday, December 11, 2011

The latest Oz reading

The comics order came this past week, so you know what that means, don't you? Oz comics! There wasn't a huge lot this month, so I'll be brief:


  • Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz #3. Yes, Eric and Skottie, usual bang-up job, probably get another Eisner, blah blah blah. But this issue sees the first big change Shanower has made in any of his comic adaptations of the Oz stories, and it's a good one. Dorothy's explanation of Ozma looking in on her, that doesn't take place until the book is nearly over? Here she gives it in the Mangaboo country, which therefore starts a ticking clock of the countdown to when Ozma will spot them and start a rescue. Genius! Oh, and also in this issue, they get to the Valley of Voe. But no encounters with bears yet. (And the cover for issue #4? Wow! That's an aspect of walking on water Baum never considered.)
  • Fables #111. Yeah, yeah search for the new North Wind is over, yada yada. Meanwhile, back in the Pan Ozian Empire things are really, really NOT looking good for Bufkin the flying monkey. Let's just say this issue ends on a cliffhanger (and if you're paying attention to that cover, you can probably guess what it is). I would wonder how he's going to get out of that, but watching Doctor Who cliffhangers for decades now makes me think there will be a way.
  • I haven't read it yet, but the collected edition of Tommy Kovac's The Royal Historian of Oz also came, and I am really looking forward to it. Not only does it have all five issues of the comic (including the never-before-published-on-paper chapter 5), it has an introduction by Eric Shanower, an excerpt from one of Jasper's Oz stories (so I guess we really can judge just how bad of an Oz author he is), the common here's-how-I-turn-a-script-into-the-finished-page feature, and a transcript of Tommy's talk at this year's Winkie Convention.

Saturday, October 15, 2011

The latest Oz reading

Not only have I entered into another cycle of Oz reading, but the comics order also arrived — and there are a lot of Oz comics! So, let's jump right in.


  • First, my latest Oz-quisition that I told you about recently, L. Frank Baum's The Uplift of Lucifer. This was, essentially, a skit he wrote for a bunch of buddies in the Los Angeles Athletic Club, which he joined not long after moving to Hollywood in 1911. Within the LAAC, a group of members formed The Uplifters, and they pretty much did whatever they felt like, I gather, including putting on little shows for the rest of the Club. It's a slight little thing, with lots of in-jokes of the times (as this was right before Prohibition, naturally there are quite a few references to the Women's Christian Temperance Union, which was spearheading the campaign, just to give one example), as well as some aimed right at the LAAC and the Uplifters themselves. I don't recommend just anyone hunt this down and read it, but Baum completists will get a kick out of it. I'd love to see this reprinted, with more background about Baum and the Uplifters, and with annotations.
  • Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz #1. It's Eric Shanower and Skottie Young, do I need to say more? This issue covers from Dorothy's arrival at Hugson's Siding to Zeb's and her spotting the Wizard in his balloon over the Mangaboo's glass city. I've heard Eric took a few more liberties with the storyline than usual, and the first big difference shows up here: Dorothy doesn't faint as the buggy is plunging through the hole. That's something that's always bugged me about the book, particularly Zeb not fainting because he's a boy. Sheesh! Oh, and for some odd reason, Eric Shanower's variant cover features Neill's version of Dorothy, not Young's.
  • A new comic series with an Ozzy bent started up, and issues 1 and 2 of Grimm Fairy Tales Presents The Library both arrived in our order. I've read #1 so far, which doesn't have any Oz content, but I gather that changes down the road. Our heroine, Sela, and her younger brother are wandering around a condemned library, when they encounter an old spell book that zaps them into some of the other books. Sounds promising, doesn't it?
  • Fables #109 gets back to what's been happening in Oz, with Jack, the Sawhorse, Bungle, and Blufkin still on the run from the Nome King's troops. It also appears that Ozma will have a hand in deciding who the new North Wind will be!
  • And there was a surprise Oz reference in Young Justince #8, which shows us what Artemis was doing during the team's fight with Amazo in one episode, and how she was recruited to join the team. It seems she's a fan of Alice in Wonderland, and refers to Superboy as the White Rabbit she's following into her version of Wonderland. However, as that leads her into a battle with a bunch of Professor Ivo's flying robot monkeys, she adds, "...maybe I landed in Oz!"

Well, that's about it for now, but I've got at least two more Oz comics and I'm in the middle of two different books right now, so there will be more updates coming soon, I'm sure.